The Short Answer
- In our view, all three towns deliver privacy. The difference is where it comes from: big lots and old oaks on flat land in Atherton, and land, slope and trees in Los Altos Hills and Woodside.
- Atherton is my pick for privacy without giving up convenience: acre lots, houses set far back from the street and protected oaks, with I-280, Highway 101 and downtown Menlo Park close by.
- In Los Altos Hills and Woodside, check the lot before you fall for the view: septic or sewer, the fire and fault maps, and how far up the hill your daily drives start.
Say you want a house you can't see from the road: oaks all around, no other houses in view. You also want coffee, Stanford or the airport to be a short drive, not an expedition.
Atherton, Los Altos Hills and Woodside, three of Silicon Valley's luxury towns, all deliver the first half. They differ on the second, so that's the lens here: privacy versus convenience, town by town.
Atherton: private, flat and central
Most of Atherton is flat oak woodland. Streets wind under the trees, with few sidewalks and minimal street lighting.
The privacy comes from the lots, not the terrain. In most of town, lots are zoned for an acre, and houses sit far back from the street and from the houses behind. Large native oaks are protected, and taller new houses must plant screening trees along the sides and back of the lot.
That's why it's my favorite of the three: privacy without the drive up a hill. I-280 runs along its western edge, Highway 101 is just east, and downtown Menlo Park is next door.
The catch: Atherton has no shops or restaurants, so most errands mean leaving town. Coffee and dinner are on tree-lined Santa Cruz Avenue in Menlo Park, and since Atherton's Caltrain station closed in 2020, the train means Menlo Park or Redwood City. In town, there's the Town Center library and Holbrook-Palmer Park's shaded paths and gardens. Homes along El Camino Real or the rail line get traffic and train noise.
Before you buy: Planning to rebuild? Start with the trees. The town won't approve a teardown or grading without an arborist's report on every protected tree. Ask about drainage, too. Federal maps show no flood zones in town, but new homes near the Atherton Channel and in lower Lindenwood usually need raised floors.
Los Altos Hills: country lanes near the valley
Los Altos Hills sits in the foothills, where orchards and ranches became homes, stables and vineyards. Before it became a town, its founders asked for "roads that are content to remain country lanes," and they got them: narrow, winding, no sidewalks, almost no streetlights.
Don't expect gates or tall walls here. Gated private roads are banned, and the town discourages entry gates and tall fences near the road. Instead, zoning calls for an acre per home and keeps houses well back from the road and each other. On ridgelines a house may have to be one story, and the steeper the lot, the less house the town allows.
I-280 runs through town, Los Altos is next door, and the town says Stanford is about 5 miles away. Near the freeway, trips are quick; up toward the ridges, drives get longer. There are no shops in town, so errands mean downtown Los Altos or Palo Alto.
In exchange, you get the outdoors: dozens of miles of walking and riding paths, Byrne Preserve's grassland and woodland, a town-owned horse barn with riding arenas, and trail links to Rancho San Antonio.
Before you buy: Ask about septic. About half the town's properties use it, and a new house or major addition may mean connecting to the sewer. Then check the town's 2025 fire map. Parts of town are rated high or very high, so look up the address and ask what that means for building and insurance.
Woodside: land first, and a small town center
Woodside runs from rolling woodland east of I-280, through a valley of oaks and grassland, up to redwood forest in the western hills. Huddart and Wunderlich county parks and watershed land border the town.
Of the three, Woodside asks for the most land. Most of the town is zoned for rural homes on 3 acres or more, with houses set well back from every property line. The town discourages solid walls in favor of low, open rail fences; distance, trees and terrain do the screening.
Convenience depends on elevation. I-280 crosses the east side, Sand Hill Road starts here and runs past Stanford, and Woodside Road leads to Redwood City. From the lower areas near the Town Center, the freeway, Stanford and Redwood City are short drives. Most Woodside roads are narrow and winding, and steep in the western hills, so trips from there take longer. Either way, you'll drive.
Woodside is the only one of the three with shops and restaurants in town. Its Town Center is a small, informal stretch of Woodside Road with Roberts Market and historic buildings. The bigger draw is the horse trail network, which the town calls unique in the Bay Area, and larger lots can have barns, stables and riding arenas. Filoli's gardens are just outside town.
Before you buy: Plan on septic. Most homes use private systems, many decades old, and most can't connect to the sewer, so have it inspected. The San Andreas Fault runs through town, and new houses must stay at least 50 feet from active fault lines, so ask where the nearest one runs. Some Woodside addresses toward Skyline are county land, with different rules.
What this means for buyers
All three towns can hide a house from the road. In my opinion, Atherton gives up the least convenience to do it, so I'd look there first. If land, trails and horses matter more, Los Altos Hills and Woodside earn the extra miles. Before you commit, drive your real week from the real address: coffee, groceries, the rush-hour commute.
Once you've chosen, be ready to move. When we won a North Los Altos home against multiple offers, our buyers had already thought through where the price could land, and the home appraised at our price. That preparation is what our buying plan is built for.
Questions, Answered
Atherton vs. Los Altos Hills vs. Woodside: which is most convenient?
In our view, Atherton. It's mostly flat and sits in the middle of the Peninsula, with I-280 on its western edge, Highway 101 just to the east and downtown Menlo Park next door. Los Altos Hills borders Los Altos, I-280 runs through it, and the town says Stanford is about 5 miles away. There, convenience depends on how far up the hill a home sits. In Woodside, the lower areas near the Town Center are a short drive from Stanford, Menlo Park and Redwood City. Most Woodside roads are narrow and winding, and in the western hills they're steep too, so trips take longer. In all three, getting around mostly means driving.
Do homes in Los Altos Hills and Woodside have septic systems?
Many do. Los Altos Hills says about half of its properties are on the public sewer and the rest use septic tanks, and a new house or major addition may require connecting to the sewer. In Woodside, most homes run on private septic systems, many of them decades old, and the town doesn't expect many more to connect to the sewer. In either town, ask which one a home uses and have the system inspected. Atherton is served by two sanitary districts, but confirm the setup for any specific property.
What is the minimum lot size in Atherton, Los Altos Hills and Woodside?
It depends on the zone. Zoning minimums apply when land is divided, so some older lots are smaller, and state law now lets some lots in all three towns be split into two smaller ones. Atherton zones most of the town for one-acre lots; a smaller-lot zone allows about a third of an acre. Los Altos Hills calls for at least one acre per home, and when land is divided, the minimum grows with the slope. In Woodside, most of the town is zoned for lots of 3 acres or more, and large parts of the western hills call for even bigger parcels. Smaller lots, an acre or less, are mostly in the northeast and around the Town Center. Ask the town what applies to the specific lot, and whether any lots next door have been split or could be.
Do Atherton, Los Altos Hills and Woodside have downtowns?
Atherton and Los Altos Hills don't. Atherton bans commercial businesses entirely; its Town Center holds the town offices and the library, and errands mean a short drive to downtown Menlo Park. Los Altos Hills has no commercial zoning, so shopping happens in downtown Los Altos, downtown Palo Alto and Stanford Shopping Center. Woodside has a small, informal Town Center on Woodside Road, with Roberts Market and historic buildings, though most shopping is elsewhere on the Peninsula.
Sources
- Town of Atherton General Plan (adopted 2020, amended through 2026): Introduction, Land Use, Circulation, Open Space and Conservation, and Noise Elements (opens in a new tab), Town of Atherton, 2020, amended 2024-2026
- Atherton General Plan, Community Safety Element (Amended 2026): flooding, slopes, wildfire and evacuation (opens in a new tab), Town of Atherton, 2026
- SB 9 Urban Lot Split (recorded and pending lot splits) (opens in a new tab), Town of Atherton, accessed 2026-11-10
- Heritage Tree Preservation Standards and Specifications (Rev 2023) (opens in a new tab), Town of Atherton, 2023
- Building Submittals and Heritage Trees (2026 handout) (opens in a new tab), Town of Atherton Building Department, 2026
- Landscape Screening Requirements and Checklist (Rev 7/27/2022) (opens in a new tab), Town of Atherton Building Department, 2022-07-27
- Sewer (opens in a new tab), Town of Atherton, accessed 2026-11-10
- Caltrain Implements New Service Changes and Permanently Closes Atherton Station (opens in a new tab), Caltrain, 2020-12-07
- El Camino Real and Downtown Specific Plan, Chapter B: Plan Context (opens in a new tab), City of Menlo Park, 2014
- Los Altos Hills General Plan, Land Use Element (one-acre minimum, slope density, setbacks, no commercial uses) (opens in a new tab), Town of Los Altos Hills, 2008-05-08
- Los Altos Hills General Plan, Circulation and Scenic Roadways Element (opens in a new tab), Town of Los Altos Hills, 2015-06-18
- Los Altos Hills General Plan Update 2007, Introduction (shopping and services in neighboring towns) (opens in a new tab), Town of Los Altos Hills, 2007-04-26
- Los Altos Hills General Plan, Open Space and Recreation Element (Byrne Preserve) (opens in a new tab), Town of Los Altos Hills, 2007-04-26
- Fast Track Guide for New Residences (opens in a new tab), Town of Los Altos Hills, 2010-07-15
- Maximum Floor Area, Maximum Development Area and Parcel Water Budget instructions and worksheets (opens in a new tab), Town of Los Altos Hills, 2025-10-17
- About Los Altos Hills (opens in a new tab), Town of Los Altos Hills, accessed 2026-11-10
- Pathways FAQs (opens in a new tab), Town of Los Altos Hills, 2017-03-17
- Westwind Community Barn (opens in a new tab), Town of Los Altos Hills, accessed 2026-11-10
- Rancho San Antonio Preserve (opens in a new tab), Midpeninsula Regional Open Space District, accessed 2026-11-10
- Town of Los Altos Hills Sewer System Management Plan (Revision 8) (opens in a new tab), Town of Los Altos Hills, 2026-04-16
- Septic System/OWTS (opens in a new tab), Town of Los Altos Hills, accessed 2026-11-10
- Los Altos Hills General Plan, Safety Element (faults, landslides, flood areas) (opens in a new tab), Town of Los Altos Hills, 2007-11-08
- City Council Special Meeting Minutes, June 20, 2025 (fire hazard severity zones adopted based on the state maps) (opens in a new tab), Town of Los Altos Hills, 2025-06-20
- Town of Woodside General Plan 2012: Preface, Historic Overview and Town Facts (planning area includes the unincorporated land around the town, which the town does not regulate) (opens in a new tab), Town of Woodside, 2012
- Town of Woodside Residential Design Guidelines (adopted 2012, revised 2016) (opens in a new tab), Town of Woodside, 2012 (revised 2016)
- Town of Woodside Zoning Map (opens in a new tab), Town of Woodside, revised 2017-03-26
- Zoning Ordinance Development Standards: RR Zone District (opens in a new tab), Town of Woodside, rev. 2024-03-18
- Town of Woodside General Plan 2012: Open Space Element (opens in a new tab), Town of Woodside, 2012
- Town of Woodside General Plan 2012: Circulation Element (opens in a new tab), Town of Woodside, 2012
- Town of Woodside General Plan 2012: Area Plans (Town Center Area Plan) (opens in a new tab), Town of Woodside, 2012
- Town Center Area Plan Update: Citizens Advisory Committee Meeting #1 Summary Notes (opens in a new tab), Town of Woodside, 2025-08-26
- Town of Woodside General Plan 2012: Public Utilities Element (sewer and septic) (opens in a new tab), Town of Woodside, 2012
- Town of Woodside General Plan 2012: Natural Hazards and Safety Element (opens in a new tab), Town of Woodside, 2012
- County Cuts Ribbon on New Skylonda Fire Station (opens in a new tab), County of San Mateo, 2018-09-19
- Skylonda Fire Station No. 58 Replacement Project (17290 Skyline Blvd., unincorporated San Mateo County next to the Town of Woodside) (opens in a new tab), State of California CEQAnet (lead agency: County of San Mateo), 2015-12-28
- Sand Hill Road (opens in a new tab), Wikipedia, accessed 2026-11-10
- California State Route 84 (opens in a new tab), Wikipedia, accessed 2026-11-10
- Sewer Services (properties outside the Town's sewer areas and districts are on septic) (opens in a new tab), Town of Woodside, accessed 2026-11-10









.jpg&w=3840&q=75)

